By Sarah Ugue
Reviewed by S.L. Botts
In An Historical Enquiry into the Probable Causes of the Rationalist Artworks Lately Predominant in the Western Art World, Ugue embarks on a rigorous and exhaustive exploration of the intellectual and cultural forces that have shaped the ascendance of rationalist aesthetics in modern and contemporary art. This ambitious work weaves together history, philosophy, and art criticism into a dense but rewarding narrative that interrogates the very foundations of our artistic values.
The book’s central thesis posits that the dominance of rationalist art forms—artworks that emphasize logic, structure, and intellectual engagement over emotional or sensory impact—can be traced to a confluence of historical developments, including the Enlightenment, industrialization, and the rise of analytic philosophy. Ugue argues that these forces have not only influenced the art itself but have also conditioned the tastes of Western audiences to favour the cerebral over the visceral, the conceptual over the expressive.
A Scholarly Dive into Art’s Intellectual Evolution
The book unfolds in three distinct sections, each building upon the other to form a compelling argument. In the first section, the author traces the roots of rationalist aesthetics to Enlightenment ideals, particularly the emphasis on reason as the highest form of human achievement. Through meticulous analysis, the text connects the rise of minimalist and conceptual art to these intellectual traditions, showing how artists like Sol LeWitt and Donald Judd inherit the legacy of rationalism as much as they react against prior movements.
The second section takes a broader cultural lens, examining how industrialization and the scientific revolution instilled a preference for efficiency, order, and systems thinking. Here, the author deftly draws parallels between the factory floor and the gridded canvases of Piet Mondrian, suggesting that the visual language of rationalism is, at its core, the language of the modern world.
Finally, the third section delves into the reception of rationalist art, exploring the ways in which institutions, critics, and collectors have elevated such works as embodiments of intellectual sophistication. The work is unflinching in its critique of the art world’s complicity in reinforcing this trend, yet the tone remains analytical rather than polemical.
Dense but Rewarding
While the book’s insights are profound, its academic style may deter some readers. The prose is dense, packed with historical references and theoretical frameworks that demand careful attention. Terms like “aesthetic epistemology” and “structural semiotics” appear frequently, making this work best suited for readers with a strong background in art history or cultural theory.
However, for those willing to engage with its complexity, the rewards are substantial. The author’s ability to synthesize ideas from diverse fields is nothing short of remarkable. Particularly striking is their discussion of how rationalist art intersects with contemporary technology, suggesting that the digital age has both amplified and problematized the rationalist paradigm.
A Timely Contribution
At a time when the art world is increasingly polarized—between calls for a return to the expressive and the continued dominance of the conceptual—An Historical Enquiry offers a timely and necessary examination of how we arrived at this juncture. While the book does not prescribe a clear path forward, it equips readers with the tools to critically evaluate the assumptions underlying contemporary art.
Ultimately, An Historical Enquiry into the Probable Causes of the Rationalist Artworks Lately Predominant in the Western Art World is a monumental achievement, one that will surely become a cornerstone text for scholars and critics seeking to understand the intellectual currents shaping Western art. It is not an easy read, but it is an essential one.