Dr Lucin Varga is spokesman for The Transeuropean Continuum of Pure Form (TCPF), a group of abstract artists who believe in the superiority of abstract art over every other art form. The group was founded in 1932 by Herr Robin Singly in Budapest.
Dear Sirs and Madams,
I write on behalf of The Transeuropean Continuum of Pure Form, a pan-European association of artists, theorists, and institutions committed to the preservation and advancement of abstraction as the only serious visual language remaining to us.
I have read the Pre-Abstractionist Manifesto with a mixture of disbelief and a kind of exhausted sorrow. One expects polemic in art, even denunciation. What I did not expect was such an enthusiastic return to error, dressed up as courage.
Had we still been living in an age of honour, I would by now have sent a second letter: a glove dropped, a time named, pistols or rapiers agreed upon. Sadly, we live in an era of emails, panels, and funding applications. So instead I must content myself with words, though I assure you they are chosen with care and anger.
To call abstraction “a mistake” is not merely wrong; it is catastrophically illiterate. Abstraction was not an escape from the world but its final comprehension. When Kandinsky abandoned the object, he did not abandon meaning, no, he discovered it. When Malevich painted the Black Square, he did not erect a tombstone; he cleared a site. Everything serious that followed had to reckon with that clearing.
Your so-called return to the “real” is not radical. It is reactionary. It is the comfort of recognition masquerading as bravery. The hand, the tree, the face, yes, we know them. Everyone knows them. They are the alphabet of visual culture. To repeat them endlessly is not devotion; it is stagnation.
Let us be frank. All non-abstract art today, no matter how skilful, no matter how anguished its subject, functions as graphic design. Illustration for ideas already formed. Decoration for narratives already written. Abstraction alone confronts the viewer with something irreducible, something that cannot be paraphrased or explained away.
You accuse abstraction of purity. You are correct, for that is its strength. Purity is not poison; it is discipline. It is the refusal to pander, to narrate, to flatter the eye with recognition. Abstract art does not reassure. It demands.
Europe learned this lesson at great cost. We learned it in the rubble of representation, in the failure of images to save us, to warn us, to redeem us. To now propose a wholesale return to figuration as a moral or aesthetic correction is not only naïve, it is dangerous.
You are, of course, entitled to paint as you wish. History will absorb you, as it absorbs all revivals, all corrections, all nostalgias. But do not mistake your protest for inevitability. Abstraction is not a phase to be overcome. It is the condition of serious art after modernity.
With indignation and regret,
Dr. Lucien Varga