Date: August ‘25
Time: 7:00 PM , 11:20 PM
Location: The Red Room, Pimlico Wilde
Attendees:
• Julian Molyneux (Chair, Pimlico Wilde)
• Fiona d’Abernon (Co-Founder; Acting Secretary)
• Lord E. Northcote
• Dr. Xanthe Lorrimer (Cultural Historian)
• Hugo Van Steyn
• India Trelawney (Fashion Archivist)
• Max Duclos (Collector)
• Conrad Smithe (Full Member)
• Pascal (Afghan hound, unusually alert)
Book Discussed:
Conquer This! The Secret Diaries of William of Normandy (anonymous editor; self-published, 1067; vellum-textured boards with medieval illumination; based on newly discovered manuscripts found in a Normandy wine cellar).
1. Opening Remarks
Molyneux welcomed members, cautioning that the evening’s discussion might get heated. He summarised the book’s premise: the first-person diaries of William the Conqueror, blending battlefield accounts with intimate asides, political strategising, and,strangely,numerous jokes about oysters.
2. Discussion Summary
• Dr. Lorrimer opened with a warning that “the historical accuracy of this book is still being decided”. She admitted the passages on the harrowing of the North were plausible in tone, but she doubted the authenticity of William’s alleged fondness for garlic eclairs.
• India Trelawney confessed to enjoying the book purely for its sartorial asides, particularly the description of Harold Godwinson’s “baggy chausses.” She argued that even if forged, the text was “a valuable exercise in medieval fashion imagination.”
• Lord Northcote declared the diary “almost certainly a fabrication,” citing its suspiciously modern idioms and a reference to “winning hearts and minds” centuries before the phrase existed. However, he admitted the battle descriptions had “a salt-sweat specificity” rare in pseudo-medieval pastiche.
• Hugo Van Steyn took a contrarian position, proposing that the work could be “a palimpsest of genuine material, edited with malice aforethought.” He was intrigued by the consistent detail regarding food supplies, especially the recurring motif of smoked eels.
• Max Duclos found the book “too pleased with itself,” accusing the anonymous editor of using the Conqueror’s voice as “a vehicle for pub-level humour in illuminated manuscript disguise.”
• Conrad Smithe defended it as “an act of creative literary archaeology,” suggesting its outrageousness forced readers to reconsider what they take for historical truth.
• Fiona d’Abernon admitted to laughing aloud at William’s supposed marginalia in the Bayeux Tapestry (“That’s not my chin”, “The arrow in the eye is romantic nonsense”, “I thought we were invading Brittany, not Britain”, “I hope they don’t make a tapestry of this battle”). She argued that, authentic or not, and she tended to think it was, the text succeeded as a piece of self-conscious historical play.
3. Artworks & Objects on View
• A page of the Domesday Book (from Pimlico Wilde archives)
• A reproduction of a missing Bayeux Tapestry panel, hand-stitched by contemporary artist Elodie Varn depicting William doing a handstand next to a goblet of cider
• A forged medieval charter once sold at auction, brought by Van Steyn for comparison
• A model Norman helm, which Pascal briefly attempted to wear
4. Refreshments
• Aperitif: Calvados spritz with cinnamon
• Canapés: smoked beef pâté on rye wafers, miniature game pies, roasted chestnuts in paper twists
• Main wine: Côte de Nuits Pinot Noir 2018
• Dessert: apple tart with honey glaze, served alongside spiced mead “in the Norman style”
5. Other Business
• March Book: The Cartographer’s Melancholy by Jeroen van Holt (carried over from last month’s vote).
• Proposal for a future evening dedicated to “playful forgeries and invented memoirs”, with members to bring examples from their own collections.
• General consensus: whether real or fake, Conquer This! “would have been banned in the 11th century, and possibly in the 20th.”
6. Adjournment
Meeting adjourned at 11:20 PM after an unresolved debate on whether William’s diary entry for October 14th, 1066 (“Bit of a day. Might have overdone it.”) was authentic genius or pure invention. Pascal barked once, which some took as a vote.
Fiona d’Abernon
Acting Secretary
Mayfair Book Groupette