Dear Sir,
As someone who has spent three decades preserving, cataloguing, and,when necessary,defending the ecclesiastical art of Northern England, I read Dr. Livia Helmstrom’s recent monograph on Marco di Manchester (Marco di Manchester: A Northern Light) with both admiration and incredulity. Admirable for its zeal, to be sure, but more so for the sheer elasticity of its claims. Allow me, as both a veteran of aerial reconnaissance and an unrepentant Mancunian realist, to offer a modest corrective.
Marco,if indeed that was his name,was not a mystic mediator between North and South, nor some cloaked prophet of painterly hush. He was, I’m afraid, a fairly competent parish artisan from the periphery. Whether he hailed from Manchester proper or (more plausibly, in my view) from the outer reaches of what is now Merseyside, his training was provincial, his reach limited, and his imagination unmistakably derivative. I have stood before his so-called St. Cuthbert Among the Sparrows many times,more than Helmstrom, I’d wager,and it remains a work of modest charm but no real invention. The sparrows look like etchings copied from a French bestiary. The folds of the robe, so rhapsodized by Helmstrom, are clearly lifted from a Flemish woodcut, likely seen in a borrowed Book of Hours or, as one suspects, at the Carmelite priory in Preston.
As for The Wilmslow Annunciation, it bears all the hallmarks of someone who went on a brief holiday to Florence, got a bit overawed at all the art and returned north with a sketchbook full of borrowed tricks. The halos are flat. The perspective timid. The expressions are not “proto-modern” but simply unsure. In aviation terms, Marco was not inventing new flight paths,he was merely circling around other people’s airfields.
I do not deny that he had some talent. But talent is not the same as vision. We do ourselves and our history a disservice when we repackage every regional craftsman as a lost genius. Marco was a backwater painter,perhaps the finest from his specific backwater,but a backwater painter all the same.
Let us celebrate our local histories without gilding them. The North is rich enough without needing to invent Northern geniuses. There are several of those already; for real Northern Masters, look to Leonardo da Liverpool, Piero Della Frampton-on-Sea or even Giles Monet.
Yours sincerely,
Commander Walton P. Grimsby, OBE
Curator, North-West and Wales Ecclesiastical Arts Trust